Companies exploiting welfare system by using residents as 'cash cows', BBC finds
0 / 96
English
中文
Watch: How private companies are cashing in on social housing Some private companies are making huge profits and exploiting the welfare system by receiving housing benefits on behalf of residents but failing to give them the support they are required to, BBC Panorama has found.
（暂无翻译）
Property agents are drawing people into the taxpayer-funded system using social media videos that offer free rooms, PlayStation consoles and even holidays.
（暂无翻译）
The system - called supported exempt accommodation (SEA) - is designed for people in the UK with additional needs, including former prisoners, people recovering from addiction and women fleeing domestic abuse.
（暂无翻译）
It provides housing along with care, support and supervision. For many residents it works well to help them get back on their feet, but charities, politicians and residents tell us parts of the system are being exploited.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
There are often complicated, multi-layered financial and management arrangements in place.
（暂无翻译）
Rather than going to residents, most welfare payments are made to non-profit registered providers.
（暂无翻译）
In many cases these providers then hire profit-making private companies to manage properties and deliver support. Many vulnerable people are being used as "cash cows to generate income" that goes from the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) into "the back pocket of the landlords", said Patricia Coleman-Taylor, who runs Birmingham anti-poverty charity Narthex.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
Panorama has learned the DWP paid out £410m for SEA in Birmingham alone in the last financial year.
（暂无翻译）
The city is the epicentre of the sector, with more than 34,000 people living in SEA.
（暂无翻译）
For context, in London about 22,000 live in supported housing despite its population being more than seven times larger. Labour MP Jess Phillips, whose Birmingham constituency contains large numbers of these properties, said companies spending taxpayers' money while providing a poor standard of support was "an absolute catastrophe" and bad landlords "can make loads of money".
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
But she added that there are some housing providers who "get this money who are absolutely providing supported accommodation".
（暂无翻译）
The leader of the city council, Liberal Democrat Councillor Roger Harmer, told us that "taxpayers' money is being wasted.
（暂无翻译）
It's a scandal." In Birmingham, BBC Panorama's investigation found: Vulnerable people are being left with little to no support in often unsuitable accommodation One big housing provider wrote off £1.8m because of payments to some former directors and companies they ran Evidence that some are willing to make benefit claims for people who do not live in their properties Supported accommodation was set up for people like Alysha.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
When she escaped a violent relationship, she returned to Birmingham seeking shelter.
（暂无翻译）
But her family did not have room so she had to look elsewhere.
（暂无翻译）
Alysha became homeless after experiencing domestic abuse in a relationship Alysha lived in three different SEA properties, including a shared house managed by a company called Second City Support Ltd.
（暂无翻译）
Things soon started to unravel, she told us.
（暂无翻译）
Last December, residents of the house went eight days without any heating or hot water when the boiler broke, she says.
（暂无翻译）
"I was at my wits' end. I'd be begging [Second City] and they would just cut the call because they didn't want to deal with it."
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
As a survivor of domestic abuse, she also wanted help to get her life on track, including looking for a job, but said there was no support from Second City.
（暂无翻译）
By law, the registered provider of the accommodation only needs to offer "more than minimal" care.
（暂无翻译）
"On the [social media] adverts, they will often say that you have weekly support sessions, help with GPs. It's not the case at all, they're not interested.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
They come, they want you to sign a paper to say, yes, Alysha's gone to support [sessions] this week." A closer examination of Alysha's shared house shows how taxpayers' money is used and how companies in the system can make money in other ways too.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
The registered provider of the supported exempt accommodation was Dawson Housing, a not-for-profit.
（暂无翻译）
Dawson Housing was being paid £443 a week in housing benefit from the DWP - which it received via Birmingham City Council - for Alysha's room and her support costs, equivalent to £23,000 a year.
（暂无翻译）
Dawson Housing hired Second City Support Ltd to manage it and deliver her support. Why are vulnerable people, including victims of domestic violence and those facing homelessness, not getting the supported housing they’ve been promised? Separately, a sister company, Second City Housing Properties, had bought and sold the house for a substantial profit.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
Land Registry records show it bought the property for £191,000 in 2024 and sold it a year later for £410,000.
（暂无翻译）
Both Second City companies are owned by Darren Davey.
（暂无翻译）
He told Panorama that his company had spent about £150,000 on renovation and other associated costs, prior to the sale.
（暂无翻译）
Davey has been very successful in profiting from housing vulnerable people in recent years, operating in both the supported exempt and temporary accommodation sectors.
（暂无翻译）
An analysis of his companies' records shows that over the past three financial years, Davey has paid himself £2.9m in dividends from his network of companies, as well as earning more than £900,000 in salary.
（暂无翻译）
Davey said his salary and dividends must be considered in the context of his wider group of businesses.
（暂无翻译）
Any suggestion his earnings came entirely from supported accommodation "would be misleading", he added.
（暂无翻译）
Lawyers for Dawson Housing denied Alysha's support was poor and say that regular in-person support was provided. They said there were unavoidable interruptions in the provision of a dedicated support worker and that Dawson Housing accepted communications with her fell below the standard expected.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
The lawyers added that Dawson Housing's records did not establish that there was an eight-day period without heating or hot water.
（暂无翻译）
They said there were several call-outs for a faulty boiler and remedial action was taken.
（暂无翻译）
There are hundreds of managing agents like Second City in Birmingham. Social media accounts, particularly on TikTok, are awash with companies trying to attract people on benefits into their properties, mainly clustered around Birmingham's poorest areas.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
Panorama has also been repeatedly told about "ghost tenants" - individuals listed as residents but not actually living in properties, for whom managing agents still claim housing benefit.
（暂无翻译）
A Facebook advert we saw had one man "looking for 7/8 ghost tenants in various houses of mine".
（暂无翻译）
When we rang the number listed, a man told us he just needed Universal Credit details and National Insurance numbers. The claims would be registered to rooms in his houses but "they wouldn't actually have to live there," he said.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
He would effectively be receiving housing benefit for people who he was not accommodating or supporting.
（暂无翻译）
Experts explain these individuals may offer respondents a one-off payment or a small recurring fee for using their details, while some people may never know their details are being used.
（暂无翻译）
"That's fraud," said Jess Phillips.
（暂无翻译）
"Those people should go to prison."
（暂无翻译）
Adverts on TikTok advertise "free" rooms for people on benefits Some people said they had been moved into SEA despite them not requiring support.
（暂无翻译）
Brian Edwards told Panorama he was one of them.
（暂无翻译）
After a relationship breakdown, the 54-year-old former charity worker found himself homeless.
（暂无翻译）
Needing accommodation, he moved into a supported house provided by Windrush Alliance and managed by Nxtgen Housing Ltd.
（暂无翻译）
He said he told Nxtgen that he didn't have any support needs but believes it applied for enhanced housing benefit on his behalf anyway. Within a week, he had managed to get some contract work.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
He said that when he informed the agency, it told him if he worked, he would lose his enhanced housing benefit payment and become liable for his rent of more than £1,000 a month, or need to move.
（暂无翻译）
A year and a half later, Brian said he was still unable to work and receives little support. "If I work, I lose my housing.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
If I stay in my housing, I can't work. I've become trapped, not just trapped in housing, trapped on benefits."
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
Brian says he was accepted into supported accommodation despite not requiring support Nxtgen Housing told Panorama it had "discussed different support plan options with Brian".
（暂无翻译）
It said "he selected the support areas he considered relevant", and the support worker "subsequently worked with him on those plans". Nxtgen said it did not discourage Brian from finding employment and improving his financial circumstances.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
The government recently changed the rules to allow SEA residents to earn more without affecting their benefits.
（暂无翻译）
Panorama has discovered that the provider of Brian's house, Windrush Alliance, had to write off £1.8m due to the actions of previous directors. In 2024, a new board of directors at Windrush found "the company's current financial position has been compromised through an outflow of funds to former directors and companies under their control". The "recoverability" of the payments was deemed by the directors to be "questionable," so the fees were written off.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
Windrush Alliance did not respond to a request for comment by the BBC.
（暂无翻译）
Five of the six largest SEA providers in Birmingham, including Windrush, have been deemed to be non-compliant with the standards set by the Regulator of Social Housing.
（暂无翻译）
All five are still operating and receiving hundreds of millions of pounds in housing benefit payments.
（暂无翻译）
But the regulator announced last week that it was launching action to close one provider, Concept Housing Association, as it had "failed to address serious failings in the way it is run".
（暂无翻译）
There is no single reason why Birmingham has become the centre of this issue.
（暂无翻译）
The availability of relatively cheap three-bedroom family homes - which can quickly be turned into five or six individual rooms with shared facilities - does attract landlords.
（暂无翻译）
But many also blame poor oversight from Birmingham City Council for allowing so many conversions to take place.
（暂无翻译）
Another reason, said councillors and charities we spoke to, was that it is not actually council money that Birmingham is signing off but central government funding.
（暂无翻译）
The council simply approves the application - it does not have to pay for it.
（暂无翻译）
Councillor Roger Harmer, a Liberal Democrat who became leader of Birmingham City Council after Labour lost power in May's elections, denied that, and told Panorama his officers were working to eradicate fraud and poor provision.
（暂无翻译）
"There is a huge incentive for us to crack down on the bad providers," he said. "But the problem is you shut down one property, they can just go next door and open up in the next house," he added, pointing out that housing benefit rules were set by the DWP.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
Companies advertise rooms across Birmingham on social media In 2023, Parliament passed a bill to strengthen regulation of the supported housing sector in England. It included a new licensing scheme and a "fit and proper person" test. But more than three years on, the law is stuck in government consultations and has made no practical difference.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
A government spokesperson said it is "working to implement measures... to raise standards and drive out the minority of poor providers taking advantage of the Housing Benefit system". In Birmingham however, residents said they wanted action, not words.
（暂无翻译） （暂无翻译）
Alysha said it is "shameful that people are being paid so much money.
（暂无翻译）
There's a lot of people who are vulnerable and in need.
（暂无翻译）
I'm going to class it as neglect."
（暂无翻译）
Additional reporting by Jenny Parks and Lawrence Williams A tent city next to Mayfair: Why cutting homelessness might be harder than before What an empty car park tells us about the UK's debt problem £1bn spent housing homeless families in England Get our flagship newsletter with all the headlines you need to start the day.
（暂无翻译）
Sign up here.
（暂无翻译）
仅供学习使用，如有侵权请联系删除 · 查看原文